CNET reports on how Verizon, Sprint, and Motorola are all plotting to begin using the cell phones they manufacture as a medium to sell mp3 players. This comes just months after
Ericsson's decision to partner with Napster to deliver music via cell phones as well.
This is a classic example of how value shifts within an industry, how firms can identify what innovations will be valuable, how products get commoditized, and how industry leaders can be overthrown.
How value shifts within an industry: Right now, the money in the digital music market goes to the firms that make and manufacture mp3 players. As cell phones become viable alternatives to mp3 players, the value of an mp3 player declines. Why buy an mp3 player when the cell phone can serve the same purpose? As a result, value in the digital music market will shift from the device that stores and plays the digital music to the music itself. Firms that can distribute a large catalog of mp3s to a wide number of devices will most likely end up controlling the market.
How to identify valuable innovations: Innovations work best when they take something that is already offered and make it simpler, cheaper, or more convenient. Buying an mp3 from your cell phone whenever you want is very convenient -- far more convenient than buying it online and then having to synch it to your mp3 player. As a result, this innovation will cause people who previously were not interested in owning an mp3 player to adopt digital music; it's simply more accessible now.
How products get commoditized: This ties into how value shifts within an industry. Why pay for an mp3 player if my cell phone can play the mp3 for me? Mp3 players will begin to get commoditized, and hence there will be an opportunity to innovate the mp3 player to increase its value.
How industry leaders can be overthrown: Apple is the current leader in the digital music market. It digital music division makes the bulk of its profits from the sale of its iPod, the fashionable mp3 player that has become overwhelmingly commonplace. As a result, it has invested in technology and business processes designed to make mp3 players, and hence making mp3 players is what its digital music division does best. But now, as mp3 players get commoditized, Apple could be in a dangerous position. They will need to find a new way to cultivate value. If they fail to do so, they stand a good chance of getting overthrown.